When a repair quote lands, the real question is whether to fix it or invest in a new system. Here’s how we help homeowners decide.
Start with age
Most systems last about 12–15 years here. If yours is past 10 and facing a major repair, replacement is often the smarter long-term move. Under 10 with a minor fix? Usually worth repairing.
Do the math on the repair
A common rule of thumb: multiply the repair cost by the system’s age. If that number tops about $5,000 — or the repair is more than a third of a new system’s price — lean toward replacing.
Count the repairs
One repair is normal. Several in a year or two means the system is wearing out, and the next failure is rarely the last.
Factor in energy bills
Older systems lose efficiency. If your bills keep climbing, a new high-efficiency system can offset much of its cost over time — and qualify for rebates and tax credits.
The R-22 tipping point
Systems using R-22 (old “Freon”) are expensive to recharge since it’s been phased out. A refrigerant leak in an R-22 system usually tips the decision to replace.